
What Should I Read After Miss Marple?

If you've finished Miss Marple, read Patricia Wentworth's Miss Silver mysteries next. Miss Silver is a retired governess who knits through every interview and catches the killer anyway, and there are 32 books about her. After that, try Heron Carvic's Miss Seeton, M.C. Beaton's Agatha Raisin, Richard Osman's Thursday Murder Club and Robert Thorogood's Marlow Murder Club. My own Bob and Shirley series is on the list as well.
Agatha Christie wrote 66 detective novels and only twelve of them star Miss Marple. I consider this poor planning.
What Makes a Book Feel Like Miss Marple?
Miss Marple is an old lady in a village called St Mary Mead, and everyone assumes she's harmless. She sits there with her knitting, noticing everything, and compares each murderer to somebody she once knew in the village.
Plenty of murder mystery books have a clever detective. Far fewer have one who gets ignored at parties.
So a good Miss Marple read-alike needs a sleuth people underestimate, and a small community where everybody's business is everybody else's. No gore either. That's cosy crime in a nutshell, and Christie did a lot to invent it.
1. Patricia Wentworth - Miss Silver
Miss Maud Silver is a retired governess turned private detective. She knits baby clothes, quotes Tennyson and coughs politely before she ruins somebody's alibi.
She first appeared in Grey Mask in 1928, two years before Miss Marple's first novel. If you want more of the same, this is as close as it gets. Start with Grey Mask.
2. Heron Carvic - Miss Seeton
Miss Seeton is an art teacher who inherits a cottage in the Kent village of Plummergen. She fends off criminals with her umbrella and has no idea she's doing any detecting at all. Scotland Yard get their clues from her drawings.
These are sillier than Christie, on purpose. Start with Picture Miss Seeton.
3. M.C. Beaton - Agatha Raisin
Agatha is what you'd get if Miss Marple had a temper and a microwave. She's a retired PR boss who moves to the Cotswold village of Carsely and enters the baking competition with a shop-bought quiche. Then the judge drops dead.
Start with Agatha Raisin and the Quiche of Death. I've written a whole post on what to read if you love Agatha Raisin as well.
4. Richard Osman - The Thursday Murder Club
Four pensioners in a Kent retirement village meet on Thursdays to go through old murder files. Then a fresh murder turns up on the doorstep.
Joyce is the nearest to Miss Marple. She seems to be all cake and chatter, and she misses nothing. These make good book club books, because everyone has a favourite pensioner. If you've already read them, here's what to read after The Thursday Murder Club.
5. Robert Thorogood - The Marlow Murder Club
Judith Potts is 77, sets crosswords for the newspapers and swims naked in the Thames. One evening she hears a gunshot from her neighbour's garden, and the police don't believe her. So she teams up with a dog walker and the vicar's wife.
Thorogood created Death in Paradise, so he knows his way around a puzzle.
6. Suzy K Quinn - Bob and Shirley (my own series)
I should be honest, these are mine. Bob and Shirley are pub landlords in Great Oakley, a fictional Suffolk village. It's St Mary Mead with a quiz night. Nobody expects a pub landlord to solve a murder, which is very Miss Marple.
The books are written in alternating first person, so you get Bob's version of events and then Shirley's. They're comedy first, with more attitude than Christie would have approved of. They're free in Kindle Unlimited, and the reading order is on my books in order page.
Which One Should You Read First?
For the closest match, go for Miss Silver. For a laugh, Agatha Raisin or Bob and Shirley. For something written this century, either of the murder clubs.
And if it's the age of the sleuth you love, I've written about cozy mysteries with older protagonists too.
Your Questions About Miss Marple Read-Alikes
What should I read after Miss Marple?
Patricia Wentworth's Miss Silver books are the closest match. After those, try Miss Seeton, Agatha Raisin, The Thursday Murder Club and The Marlow Murder Club.
Are there any modern books like Miss Marple?
Yes. The Thursday Murder Club and The Marlow Murder Club both have older amateur sleuths in small English communities, and both series began in the 2020s. My Bob and Shirley books are modern too, and set in a village pub.
Which Miss Marple book should I read first?
The Murder at the Vicarage is the first novel, published in 1930. A Murder is Announced and The Body in the Library are good places to start too. Each one stands alone, so the order doesn't matter much.
Is Miss Marple a cozy mystery?
Yes. Most cozy mystery books owe her something. There's a village, an amateur sleuth and a murder that happens politely off the page. In Britain we spell it cosy crime, but it's the same genre.
Suzy xx

Comments